Which list of ingredients is more potent for a skin lightening cream/serum?

the second one sounds more legit , because it has more natural ingredients that your skin will react positively to. could you tell me the name of it? also whats beneficial about the second one is that it has added vitamins A and E, which are beneficial to help skin rejuvanate and heal from scars. btw, the first list sounds like the ingredients for hot sauce lol. i wouldnt use that!